Hong Kong: Impressive Destination, Unfinished Journey

© Earnest Tse / Adobe Stock

By Joseph Keefe

A truly global hub and still arguably the center of
Asian trade and logistics, Hong Kong nevertheless faces many

… the Port of Hong Kong saw in 2016 its lowest TEU throughput
for more than a decade. Not even a late surge in throughput in
December could prevent the less-than-rosy results. By the
numbers, Hong Kong saw a monthly 1.8 million TEU, 14 percent
increase from the same period just one year ago. But, 2016's
totals (19.6 million TEU) represented an annual drop of 2.5
percent. More worrying is that some of these individual terminals
experienced as much as a 20 percent surge in December, but much
if not all of that was a function of the Hanjin 'hangover.'

A weeklong visit to Hong Kong reveals many things about this
exotic city with its centrally located port and logistics hub.
With more than 7 million residents tightly packed into 427 square
miles, Hong Kong ranks as one of the most densely populated
places on earth. It is also one of the busiest, and its trading
economy is the world's 8th largest with international trade
facilitated by the world's 5th busiest container port, the
world's number one air cargo destination and a strong base of
shipowners, cargo owners and traders.

The autonomous, Special Administrative Region of the People's
Republic of China also boasts many other advantages that have
attracted a strong maritime presence. Over time, Hong Kong has
seen a steady expansion of its maritime services cluster,
including such businesses as ship management, ship broking, ship
finance, maritime insurance and law. All of that, in turn, has
produced enviable economic benefits in way of local job
opportunities and a high standard of living.

With 340 container liner services per week connecting to about
470 destinations worldwide, the port boasts nine container
terminals with a total of 24 berths at Kwai Chung and Tsing Yi
Island, all operated by private entities. Exports represent a
relatively small portion of Hong Kong's box traffic.

Like Charleston, South Carolina, one of Hong Kong's biggest
reasons for optimism is its geographic position. In October, for
example, local South Carolina Port Director Jim Newsome told
MLPro, "Right now, we think the Southeast is the best
place to be in the port business because we have an import growth
based on population and export growth and expanding
manufacturing." Similarly, Hong Kong is situated just four hour's
flight from virtually all of Asia's key markets and within five
hours of half of the world's population. For comparison, though,
you can fit five 'Charlestons' into the port of Hong Kong, with
room to spare.

There's more: Hong Kong today hosts the world's fourth largest
shipping register, trailing only more recognizable players like
Panama, Liberia and the Marshall Islands. Almost 2,500 vessels
were under Hong Kong flag by April of last year, representing a
whopping 104 million gross tons, and more than 150 million
deadweight tons (DWT) - about 8 percent of the world's total.
What's not to like?

Real Concerns

As it turns out, there is ample reason for concern. For example,
the Port of Hong Kong saw in 2016 its lowest TEU throughput for
more than a decade. Not even a late surge in throughput in
December could prevent the less-than-rosy results. By the
numbers, Hong Kong saw a monthly 1.8 million TEU, 14 percent
increase from the same period just one year ago. But, 2016's
totals (19.6 million TEU) represented an annual drop of 2.5
percent. More worrying is that some of these individual terminals
experienced as much as a 20 percent surge in December, but much
if not all of that was a function of the Hanjin 'hangover.'

Of bigger concern is the close proximity of another seven of the
world's top 10 boxports - all of them located next door in
Mainland China. Not too long ago, none of those neighboring ports
could boast those kinds of numbers. Such has been the explosive
regional growth, some of which came at Hong Kong's expense.

Local stakeholders are only too aware of the situation; some
worried and others, who have operations in more than one area
port, philosophical about the changing logistics trend. As for
the Hong Kong government, they are hard at work making sure that
infrastructure is not the reason that traffic continues to
decline, if only slightly.

Looking Ahead, Not Behind

Leveraging a deep-water, silt-free natural harbor located close
to the Chinese mainland, Hong Kong's evolution into a dominant
Asian sea transport hub isn't surprising. But just because Hong
Kong Port was the world's fifth busiest container port in 2015,
handling 20.1 million TEUs, doesn't mean it can sit on its hands.
Indeed, 2015 container traffic was down 9.7 percent from 2014.

Nearby Shanghai, Singapore, Shenzhen and Ningbo-Zhoushan all
boast bigger numbers, and the mainland Chinese ports are
expanding quickly. For its part, Hong Kong hangs its hat in part
on its renowned efficiency and the fact that all container
terminals are privately owned and operated. Periodic physical
enhancements and new cargo techniques have markedly raised local
handling efficiency.

Containers are not Hong Kong's only seaborne trade commodity.
During 2015, Hong Kong handled 257 million tons of seaborne and
river cargo, of which 70 percent was carried by oceangoing
vessels. This includes break bulk, oil, gas, grain, minerals and
timber. More than one-half of that, significantly, was
transshipment cargo, much of which eventually goes to the Chinese
mainland. And, as those Chinese ports get more efficient, it is
likely that some of this transshipment cargo will go away.

At the same time, regional, competing ports have developed
rapidly in recent years. Shanghai, for example, is the world's
busiest seaport, while Shenzhen was the world's third busiest
port, with 24.2 million TEUs handled in 2015. The Port of
Ningbo-Zhoushan surpassed Hong Kong to become the world's fourth
busiest in 2015, with its throughput increasing to 20.6 million
TEUs. Hong Kong meanwhile showed the least amount of growth over
the course of the past 11 years and is one of only two top 10
ports to show a decline in TEU throughput from its best year.
Singapore was the other.

A local green initiative, looking to cut stack and industrial
emissions in the port of Hong Kong has 17 Hong Kong major freight
liners have signed up the Fair Wind Charters (FWC), a voluntary
commitment to switch from high-sulphur bunker oil to 0.5 percent
sulphur diesel when berthing in Hong Kong. FWC is the world's
first shipping-industry led fuel switching initiative. That's
nice, but it also costs money and perhaps gives an (unfair)
advantage to other regional ports - Mainland China, for example,
where the air quality is notoriously bad - and where they don't
necessarily practice similar environmental stewardship.

The (Modern) HK View …

As part of MLPro's one week visit to Hong Kong in late
November, a lengthy briefing was presented by Modern Terminals
(MT) and its local General Manager of Strategy & Business
Development, Gavin Dow. MT moved 5 million TEU's at its Hong Kong
berths in 2014, or roughly one-quarter of Hong Kong's throughput.
In fact, MT's local throughput has most recently been up, whereas
Hong Kong throughput as a whole has been moving south. The 10th
largest port operator in the world, MT has been in Hong Kong
since 1972, but also operates terminals on the mainland. And,
that last factoid may be particularly important.

MT is faring well in a less-than-favorable boxship environment,
but significant challenges remain for local terminals, and the
port that hopes that their market share will rebound to previous
levels. One of those challenges involves local investment - both
in terms of money and land. And, while the terminals themselves
have made a lot of investment in last few years, the government
has not necessarily matched that effort. For one thing, the
terminals are 'land constrained' and they need as much as another
70 hectares. To be fair, the government is trying to solve this
issue, and negotiations were underway to do just that in the
latter part of 2016.

The land issue is particularly important because container
handling yards - like shipyards - need ample 'laydown' space in
order to operate efficiently and reduce container 'dwell time.'
And, said Dow, the combined [local] maximum operating capacity is
around 23-24 million TEU's. As a general rule of thumb, 80
percent of maximum capacity is also considered the point of
"maximum efficiency." With the cumulative Hong Kong port
throughput bumping up against 20 million TEU's annually, some
stakeholders consider the port to be at maximum efficiency
already. For its part, MT is even looking at multi-level truck
parking as a viable solution.

Also pushing Hong Kong to keep its foot on the gas pedal is the
significant improvement in efficiency at ports like Shenzhen,
where local operators are closing the gap quickly. As more
countries look to privatize existing port operations and develop
new ones, the development of ports on the Chinese mainland and
the wider region has challenged Hong Kong's local supremacy.
Actually, Hong Kong port operators are already active there.
Modern Terminals is one of them. Investing in and operating
several container terminals in Shenzhen, and the Yangtze River
Delta, MT can afford to hedge its bets when thinking about
regional business.

Hard at work at improving its already impressive Hong Kong
presence and efficiencies, MT does the exact same thing on the
mainland. And, improvements are arguably easier to see there than
they are at a mature terminal in Hong Kong already operating at
an enviable clip. Still another Hong Kong terminal operator,
Hutchison Port Holdings (HPH) Group, has an impressive network
that leverages 48 ports in 25 countries, and handled in excess of
80 million TEUs worldwide in 2015.

Helping the local case is the fact that Hong Kong is a 'free'
port. Even so, some Chinese ports are operating at half the price
of Hong Kong, but, says Dow, "Sticker price isn't the only
variable." Nevertheless, BIMCO, the world's largest international
shipping association, said recently that container shipping lines
received an average rate 7 percent ($42 USD) lower in 2016 than
in 2015. Hence, while price isn't the only variable, it remains
unquestionably important.

MT uses every tool at its disposal in an effort to improve its
performance, including the switch to the Navis terminal operating
software (TOS) software from an in-house proprietary system. Dow
said in November, "Some business went away in 2014, but some came
back, especially 2016. Navis was a big part of that - with
demonstrated efficiencies on throughput." Beyond this, he said,
midsize terminals like MT are looking to collaborate with others;
sharing data and safety stats as a way to improve business

In the meantime, and for shippers who care, MT's Hong Kong
operations are all ISO 14001 certified, utilizing environmentally
friendly all-electric and/or LNG equipment. Last, but certainly
not least, is talk of the relaxation of Mainland China's cabotage
rule for mainland commerce. If that happens, the exodus of cargo
to mainland ports could accelerate. That's anything but certain,
but local Hong Kong terminal operators and the local government
itself are watching that development closely.

The Good News

Like any other container port, Hong Kong and its private
operators have a keen eye on infrastructure, especially when it
comes to beefing up berths to support the new post-Panama reach
cranes. Those improvements continue at a breakneck pace because
Hong Kong's chief advantages leverage not only its naturally deep
harbors and centrally located geography, but also finely honed
efficiencies that still outpace its now bigger rivals.

In other sectors, the Kai Tak Cruise Terminal entered service in
June 2013 with rooftop and tourism-related facilities for
visitors and locals, and providing embarking and disembarking
services for cruise passengers. The terminal's capacity of
customs, immigration and health quarantine operation clearance
can serve 3,000 passengers per hour. That sector has doubled its
volume in terms of both passenger throughput and ship calls in
only three years. Local officials are doubling down on making
sure that trend continues.

Separately, and critical to the container business, the Hong
Kong-Zhuhai-Macau Bridge (HKZMB), a large-scale cross-border
infrastructure linking the three places, is expected to be
completed in 2017. Cargo movement between Hong Kong and western
Pearl River Delta will be further enhanced, eventually reducing
local road traffic, air emissions, and shortening trucking
transits to and from the local container terminals from today's 4
hours to just 45 minutes. When finally realized, those are real

A planned third runway for the world's busiest air freight hub,
nominally unrelated to maritime commercial business, will
solidify Hong Kong's position as the world's number one air
freight hub. A tour of Cathay Pacific's amazing air cargo freight
handling center at the airport revealed enviable logistics
technology and efficiencies. It is here where the maritime
cluster could take some lessons.

No less important is China's Belt & Road initiative, an
effort that envisions the integration of the region into a
cohesive economic area through infrastructure and the broadening
of trade. It is something that will eventually impact the local
maritime cluster; to what extent, that remains to be seen.

Conventional wisdom says that Hong Kong's market share of
maritime traffic (percent of regional trade in TEU's) will likely
continue to decline, even if its actual numbers begin to rise.
That's not necessarily bad news. Every port will eventually reach
maximum capacity. As the global demand for transport increases,
there will be plenty of TEU's to go around for all ports. And, it
would be a mistake to assume that Hong Kong won't continue to be
a key, if not the central hub in the region. They will.

(As published in the January/February 2017 edition of

Maritime Logistics Professional

Mar 9, 2017

Let's block ads! (Why?)

0 replies

Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.